England has three government-authorised deposit protection schemes: the Deposit Protection Service (DPS), the Tenancy Deposit Scheme (TDS) and mydeposits. The legal protection is identical across all three, and protecting a deposit in any of them satisfies your duty under the Housing Act 2004. Each offers a free custodial option and an insured option that carries a fee, so what you are choosing between is service model, cost structure and the feel of the dispute process.

The Renters’ Rights Act 2025, in force since 1 May 2026, abolished Section 21 and made every assured tenancy periodic, but it left the core deposit protection duties in place. The 30-day protection and prescribed-information duties in section 213 of the Housing Act 2004 and the one-to-three-times penalty in section 214 work as before. What changed is the sanction in section 215: since 1 May 2026 an unprotected deposit or unserved prescribed information stops the court making a possession order on any Section 8 ground except the anti-social behaviour Grounds 7A and 14, where previously it blocked a Section 21 notice. That makes choosing and using a scheme correctly more important than ever, because deposit failures now sit alongside an expanded enforcement regime that includes rent repayment orders and tougher financial penalties.

What “government-backed” actually means

There are only three deposit protection schemes authorised by the UK government to operate in England and Wales. Every penny of deposit you take for an assured tenancy must be protected in one of them within 30 days of receipt, and you must give the tenant the prescribed information about where it is held within the same window. There is no fourth option and no DIY alternative, holding a deposit in your own bank account without protecting it in one of the schemes, however carefully, is unlawful.

The three schemes are:

  • The Deposit Protection Service (DPS), run by Computershare.
  • The Tenancy Deposit Scheme (TDS), run by The Dispute Service.
  • mydeposits, run by Total Property and backed by the National Residential Landlords Association.

Each scheme offers two ways of protecting a deposit: custodial (the scheme holds the cash) and insured (you keep the cash and pay a fee to insure it). The choice between those two models matters as much as the choice of provider, we cover it in depth in our guide to custodial vs insured deposit schemes. This article focuses on comparing the three providers themselves.

Before you compare schemes, make sure you have the basics right: the deposit must not exceed the legal cap (five weeks’ rent where annual rent is under £50,000), which we explain in how much a landlord can charge as a deposit, and you should understand the wider framework set out in our overview of tenancy deposit protection in England.

The three schemes at a glance

The headline comparison is simpler than landlords expect, because the legal protection is identical across all three. What you are really choosing between is service model, cost structure and the feel of the dispute process.

Feature DPS TDS mydeposits
Operator Computershare The Dispute Service Total Property (NRLA-backed)
Custodial option Yes Yes Yes
Insured option Yes Yes Yes
Custodial cost to landlord Free Free Free
Insured fee model Per-deposit fee, no annual membership Per-deposit or membership tiers Annual fee per deposit (since July 2026)
Interest on custodial deposits Paid to the tenant (if held 183+ days) Paid to the tenant Paid to the tenant
Free dispute adjudication Yes Yes Yes
Online deposit management Yes Yes Yes
Notable strength Simple, no-cost custodial Strong adjudication heritage Tight NRLA / agent integration

Costs and fee tiers change periodically, so always confirm the current figures on each scheme’s own website before you commit. The pattern, however, is durable: custodial protection is free across all three schemes, and the insured route always carries a fee because you are paying for the convenience of keeping the cash and the insurance that backs it.

Deposit Protection Service (DPS)

The DPS is the largest custodial scheme and is often the default choice for self-managing landlords who want zero hassle and zero cost. You pay the deposit into the DPS, it sits there for the tenancy, and at the end you and the tenant agree how it is split. There is no annual fee for the custodial product and the sign-up is light. The DPS also offers an insured product for landlords and agents who prefer to retain the funds.

The trade-off is that you earn nothing on the money: once a custodial deposit has been protected for 183 days, the DPS pays the interest to the tenant at the end of the tenancy, even if you keep part of the deposit. For most landlords that is a non-issue against the benefit of never touching the cash and never being accused of withholding it.

Tenancy Deposit Scheme (TDS)

TDS grew out of the dispute-resolution world and has a long-standing reputation for the quality and consistency of its adjudication. If you anticipate the occasional contested end-of-tenancy, for example because you let larger or higher-value properties, landlords often value the depth of TDS’s adjudicator decisions and its published guidance on what evidence persuades. TDS offers both custodial and insured products, with the insured route available on a per-deposit basis or through membership tiers aimed at agents and portfolio landlords.

mydeposits

mydeposits is closely integrated with the National Residential Landlords Association and is popular with members and with letting agents who manage deposits at scale. Its insured product is a natural fit if you already keep deposits in a client or business account and want the lightest-touch way to insure them. Like the others, mydeposits offers a free custodial option and free adjudication.

Custodial vs insured: the choice inside each scheme

Because all three providers offer both models, your first decision is often which model rather than which brand. In one line: custodial costs nothing and the scheme holds the money; insured lets you keep the cash in your own account for a fee. The full comparison, with the cash-flow arithmetic and a decision framework, is in custodial vs insured deposit schemes: which should you use?. The rest of this guide is about the three providers themselves.

One thing to watch: in June 2026 the government proposed removing insured schemes from a reformed deposit protection system. On 11 November 2026 no timetable has been announced and both models remain lawful, and the comparison guide above tracks what changes. To see which model costs less for your own tenancies, use our free deposit scheme chooser.

A worked example: choosing and protecting a deposit

Priya lets a two-bedroom flat in Leeds at £1,100 a month. The annual rent is £13,200, comfortably under the £50,000 threshold, so the deposit cap is five weeks’ rent.

Step 1, calculate the cap. Weekly rent is £1,100 × 12 ÷ 52 = £253.85. Five weeks is £1,269.23. Priya takes a deposit of £1,250, safely under the cap.

Step 2, choose a scheme and model. Priya self-manages and does not want the money on her books, so she chooses a custodial scheme. She compares the three and picks the DPS for its no-cost simplicity, though TDS or mydeposits custodial would have served equally well.

Step 3, protect within 30 days. Priya receives the deposit on 3 July and pays it into the DPS on 9 July, well within the 30-day deadline.

Step 4, serve the prescribed information. By the same 30-day deadline she gives the tenant the prescribed information, including the scheme name and contact details, the deposit amount, the property address, her own and the tenant’s contact details, the circumstances in which deductions may be made, how to apply for the deposit back, what happens in a dispute, and the scheme’s leaflet. She keeps a dated copy.

Step 5, document the property’s condition. Priya prepares a detailed inventory with photographs and gets it signed at check-in. Without it, she would struggle to justify any deduction, see do you legally need an inventory to protect a tenancy deposit.

Step 6, at the end of the tenancy. Priya proposes returning £1,150 and deducting £100 for a damaged blind beyond fair wear and tear. She sets this out in a clear letter, our deposit return letter template covers the wording. The tenant disagrees, so the disputed £100 goes to the scheme’s free adjudication while the undisputed £1,150 is released promptly. The adjudicator reviews the inventory and check-out report and splits the difference. Total cost to Priya: nothing but a little time.

This is exactly the flow all three schemes are built to handle. The brand mattered far less than getting the process right.

Why getting protection right matters more in 2026

Deposit protection is not just good practice, it is enforced. If you fail to protect a deposit or to serve the prescribed information within 30 days:

  • A court can order you to repay the deposit or pay it into a scheme, and to pay the tenant a penalty of between one and three times the deposit.
  • The court cannot make a possession order on any Section 8 ground except the anti-social behaviour Grounds 7A and 14 until the deposit is protected and the prescribed information given, the deposit is returned (in full or with agreed deductions), or the tenant’s court claim about it is decided, withdrawn or settled.
  • The breach can feed into the broader enforcement landscape, local authorities have expanding powers, and unprotected deposits can be a red flag in wider compliance reviews. See our rundown of landlord fines in England 2026.

The Renters’ Rights Act kept these core deposit rules (only the possession bar moved from Section 21 notices to Section 8 possession orders), but by removing Section 21 it removed the easy “no-fault” exit that some landlords previously leaned on. With possession now running through Section 8 grounds, the integrity of your paperwork, including deposit protection, is under sharper scrutiny than before.

How disputes work across the three schemes

Every authorised scheme provides free, impartial alternative dispute resolution (ADR) at the end of a tenancy. The mechanics are broadly the same whichever provider you use:

  1. The landlord proposes deductions; the tenant agrees or disputes.
  2. The undisputed portion is repaid.
  3. The disputed amount is held by the scheme (always so in custodial; the insured landlord must hand it over).
  4. Both sides submit evidence, inventory, check-in and check-out reports, photographs, receipts, correspondence.
  5. An independent adjudicator decides, and the decision is final and binding.

The adjudicator starts from the position that the deposit is the tenant’s money and that the burden is on the landlord to justify every deduction with evidence. This is why your inventory and check-out report carry far more weight than the scheme you picked. Tenants can read the mirror-image of this process in how to dispute unfair deposit deductions.

A practical point: ADR is voluntary for both parties. If either side refuses to use it, the matter can only be resolved in the county court, slower, costlier and with no free adjudicator. Using the scheme’s ADR is almost always the smarter route.

Switching schemes or models

You can move a deposit between schemes or between custodial and insured during a tenancy, but you must do it carefully. The deposit must remain continuously protected and the prescribed information must be reissued to reflect the new arrangement. The cleanest moment to switch is at the start of a new tenancy. Mid-tenancy switching is possible but introduces avoidable risk if a deadline is missed, so if you do it, document every step and date.

Frequently asked questions

Yes. The DPS, TDS and mydeposits are the only three government-authorised schemes operating in England, and protecting a deposit in any of them satisfies your duty under the Housing Act 2004. The legal protection is identical; only the service, cost and dispute experience differ. That is why this comparison focuses on practicalities rather than legality.

Which deposit scheme is cheapest?

The custodial product is free in all three schemes, so cost is rarely a deciding factor if you go custodial. The insured products carry a fee, either per deposit or as an annual membership, and the cheapest option depends on how many deposits you hold. A single-property landlord usually finds per-deposit insured cheapest; a portfolio landlord or agent usually finds a membership tier better value. Always check current pricing on each scheme’s site.

Can I keep the deposit in my own bank account if I insure it?

Only under an insured scheme, and only if you protect it and serve the prescribed information within 30 days. You keep the cash, pay the insurance fee, and must hand any disputed amount to the scheme if there is a disagreement at the end. Keeping a deposit in your own account without an insured (or custodial) protection in place is unlawful and exposes you to the one-to-three-times penalty.

Do I earn interest on a custodial deposit?

No. Under all three custodial products any interest the deposit earns is paid to the tenant under the scheme’s terms, not to the landlord. If earning interest matters to you, an insured product lets you hold the cash yourself, but weigh that small gain against the fee and the extra responsibility of holding and repaying the money.

Did the Renters’ Rights Act 2025 change deposit protection?

Only in one important respect. The Act abolished Section 21, ended fixed terms and made all assured tenancies periodic. The 30-day deadline, the prescribed information duty, the five-week cap and the one-to-three-times penalty all still apply as before. What changed is the possession consequence: since 1 May 2026 a court cannot make a possession order on any Section 8 ground, except the anti-social behaviour Grounds 7A and 14, while the deposit is unprotected or the prescribed information unserved, unless the deposit has been returned or a court claim about it has been resolved.

What happens to the deposit when a fixed term would once have ended?

Because all tenancies are now periodic and roll on indefinitely until ended properly, there is no “renewal” point that resets deposit protection. The deposit stays protected throughout. You do not need to re-protect it simply because time passes, only if you change scheme, change model, or the deposit amount changes.

This article is general information, not legal advice. Deposit rules and scheme details change, always verify the current position on GOV.UK and legislation.gov.uk, confirm fees directly with each scheme, and consult a qualified solicitor about your specific circumstances.

Share

Coming soon: Tenancy Pilot

Tenancy Pilot will track each deposit deadline with alerts and include generators for your deposit return letter, inventory and prescribed information pack, so the paperwork is ready before you need it. It is not live yet. Join the waitlist to hear when it opens.